Yes...I still keep looking for reds. I'm hooked on the hunt!
I found OPI Off With Her Red in the clearance bin at Ulta for $3, and I'm not sure what possessed me to buy it. It looked really orange-y, muddy, and just not appetizing. But I bought it. The thing that I've learned about reds is that they rarely seem to look the same in the bottle and on the nail, so I took a chance.
And I'm so glad I did!! Here it is...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/412d4/412d4bfac946a1c787f5a364962b0db63a841d69" alt=""
I lllooooovvveee it! Instead of looking muddy on me, it looks clear and crisp, without being crazy bright. Orange-toned reds suit my yellow skin best, and in the bottle it seemed overly orange - but I think it works!!
What do you think? Is there a colour you keep picking up trying to find the "ultimate"?
kittytokaren